The Paradox of the Bodhisattva Vows: Revealing the Buddha Way

-

 

Ah

The Four Bodhisattva Vows are among the most well-known and profound commitments in Mahāyāna Buddhism. At first glance, they appear paradoxical, even impossible to fulfill:

Sentient beings are numberless; I vow to save them all.

Delusions are inexhaustible; I vow to end them.

Dharma gates are boundless; I vow to master them.

The Buddha way is unsurpassable; I vow to attain it.

Taken literally, these vows seem unattainable. How can one possibly save an infinite number of beings? How can one end delusions that continuously arise? How can one master all Dharma teachings or attain an unsurpassable path? However, these vows are not meant to be fulfilled in a linear or conventional sense. Instead, they serve as a profound upāya (skillful means) to dissolve self-centered limitations and awaken one to the nature of reality.

Saving All Beings: The Non-Dual View

The first vow, "Sentient beings are numberless, I vow to save them all," seems impossible if we think of it in terms of an external mission to rescue others. However, from the perspective of Mahāyāna and Vajrayāna teachings, this vow is understood through the realization of śūnyatā (emptiness) and tathāgatagarbha(Buddha-nature).

In the Dhammapada, the Buddha states that no one purifies another; each being must awaken for themselves. If this is the case, what does it mean to "save all beings"? The answer lies in perception. Liberation is not about changing others but about realizing that all beings are already enlightened in their true nature. The bodhisattva does not impose salvation onto others but rather awakens to the truth that self and other are not separate.

To liberate all sentient beings is to liberate oneself from the illusion of separateness. In this way, the vow is fulfilled not by accumulating countless acts of salvation but by dissolving the dualistic perception that sees beings as inherently trapped.

Ending Delusions: Seeing Through Illusion

The second vow, "Delusions are inexhaustible, I vow to end them," presents a similar challenge. If delusions are inexhaustible, how can one possibly put an end to them?

Here, the Heart Sūtra offers an essential insight:

"No ignorance and also no ending of ignorance... No wisdom and no attainment, with nothing to attain."

Delusions do not need to be eradicated one by one; rather, their nature must be seen through. Delusions exist only because they are grasped as real. The moment one realizes their emptiness, they lose their power.

To "end delusions" does not mean eliminating every passing thought but awakening to their illusory nature. When one no longer clings to them, delusions cease to function as obstacles.

Mastering Dharma Gates: The One Truth

With boundless Dharma gates, how can one possibly master them all? This third vow points to the vastness of the Buddhist teachings, each adapted to different beings and circumstances. However, all Dharma gates ultimately lead to a singular realization: the nature of mind and reality.

The mastery of all teachings is not about accumulating infinite knowledge but about realizing the fundamental truth they all point to. In Zen, this is often likened to knowing the taste of water—once understood, all rivers and streams are recognized as the same.

Attaining the Buddha Way: The Unattainable is Already Present

The final vow, "The Buddha way is unsurpassable, I vow to attain it," seems contradictory in light of the Heart Sūtra, which states that there is "no attainment and nothing to attain."

Buddhahood is not something one acquires; it is something one uncovers. To "attain" the Buddha way is to reveal one's own Buddha-nature, which has never been absent.

Many Mahāyāna and Vajrayāna teachings emphasize that enlightenment is not created or gained but simply recognized. As the Hua-Yan school states:

"From the very beginning, all beings are Buddhas."

The moment one stops seeking enlightenment as something external and realizes that it is already present, the vow is fulfilled.

The Bodhisattva Path as a Realization, Not an Achievement

The Four Bodhisattva Vows are not meant to be accomplished in a conventional sense. Instead, they serve as a framework for dissolving the illusion of a separate self and awakening to the nature of reality. Each vow, though seemingly outward-focused, ultimately points inward.

To save all beings is to awaken to non-duality.

To end delusions is to cease grasping at illusions.

To master Dharma gates is to realize their common truth.

To attain the Buddha way is to reveal what was never absent.

The paradox is resolved: one does not "attain" Buddhahood. Instead, one becomes the Buddha Way by revealing their own innate nature. This is the essence of Mahāyāna and Vajrayāna realization, where the bodhisattva vows are not external missions but direct pathways to awakening.

Popular posts from this blog

Pure Land Buddhism: Theory and Practice

-
Image
Introduction It is easy to critique Pure Land Buddhism in its current modus operandi. I do it myself. It’s an easy target because of its façade of superstition and magic, religious overtones and seemingly exotic teachings with its dependence on the “one true Buddha”. They really don’t say, “one true Buddha”, I sort of made that up myself. And it does seem sort of odd to walk into a Buddhist temple to find a very Protestant Christian looking and sounding service. But not all Pure Land schools operate the same way. Some are very “protestant like” and others are very traditional. It depends on which school is hosting the service.       Recently while presenting a talk on the Buddhist Doctrine of Mind at the Jung Center of Chicago a member of the audience came to me and said she had been studying Buddhism for 10 years and just could not understand the Pure Land Buddhists because they thought they could be saved by simply chanting “Amitabha Buddha” over and over aga...
Read more

The Protection Wheel of Vajra Armor

-
Image
"As I explore the wilderness of my own body, I see I Am made of blood and bones, sunlight and water, pesticide and redwood humus, the fear and dreams of generations of ancestors, particles of exploded stars” I don’t now who actually said this but the quote is found on Pinterest in a dozen or so places. It is a wonderful “mantra” to use when reminding ourselves that our body is not who we are. Not are we our mind.   According to the Buddha, self is not truth. He declared," Where self is, truth is not. Where truth is, self is not. Self is the fleeting error of samsara; it is individual separateness and that egotism which begets envy and hatred." He defined self as "that yearning which seeks pleasure and lusts after vanity where as Truth is the correct comprehension of things, which is the permanent and everlasting, the real in all existence and the bliss of righteousness." The very existence of self is an illusion,. It is the Self, which through...
Read more

A Little Something About Pure Land Buddhism

-
Image
Three Pure Land Sages Bishop Koshin Ogui of the Buddhist Churches of America introduced me to Pure Land Buddhism in the 1990s. He also recognized me as ordained clergy and gave me my Dharma name. At the time he was the Master at a Jodo Shin Temple in Cleveland. Ogui was also the Master at the Midwest Buddhist Temple in Chicago. A remarkable man and teacher he was instrumental in my taking on the unified practice he held so dear. The emphasis of my practice varies with my needs. This is the way the Buddha taught. One size does not fit all any more than one tool in the box is sufficient for all jobs.   One of the main themes he emphasized was the unified practice. This is where Jodo and Zen are combined into one integrated whole. The Chinese invented this method thousand or so years ago. Tendai and its predecessor T’ien T’ai demanded this method of unifying practices. Since each being is unique, each being responds best to a unique practice.   Based on what I ...
Read more